A month-to-month lease gives landlords and tenants more freedom than a year-long lease. However, that does not mean a landlord can end the agreement whenever they want.
New York has rules about how much notice a landlord must give and when they can ask a tenant to leave. A New York City landlord lawyer can help property owners understand these rules and avoid mistakes that could delay the process.
What Is a Month-to-Month Lease?
A month-to-month lease is a rental agreement that renews each month. It has no set end date.
This arrangement may begin when a tenant moves in without a written lease. It can also happen when a yearly lease ends, but the tenant stays, and the landlord continues accepting rent. Both landlords and tenants can end these agreements, but they must follow the law.
How Much Notice a Landlord Must Give
Under New York law, landlords must give tenants written notice before ending a month-to-month tenancy. The required notice depends on how long the tenant has lived in the home or the length of their lease:
- 30 days: The tenant has lived there for less than one year and has no lease lasting a year or longer.
- 60 days: The tenant has lived there for at least one year but less than two years, or has a lease term of that length.
- 90 days: The tenant has lived there for two years or longer, or has a lease term of at least two years.
The notice must state when the tenancy will end.
How to Deliver the Notice Properly
After writing the notice, landlords must ensure it reaches the tenant in a way the law allows. A phone call or text message is not enough. Landlords must deliver the notice using proper legal methods, such as personal delivery or other methods allowed by the court.
If they deliver the notice incorrectly, a judge may dismiss the eviction case. The landlord may then have to start over. Landlords must also include a notice explaining whether the Good Cause Eviction Law covers the property. If the property is exempt, the notice must explain why.
Does a Landlord Need a Reason to End the Lease?
New York’s Good Cause Eviction Law protects many tenants, including some who rent month to month. When this law applies, landlords must have a valid reason to end the tenancy. These reasons may include not paying rent, breaking important lease terms, causing serious problems at the property, and qualifying, good-faith owner occupancy. Owner occupancy must meet statutory conditions, including use as a principal residence and no other suitable unit in the building; it cannot be used against tenants age 65 or older or tenants with disabilities.
Some properties are exempt from this law. Rent-stabilized apartments also have their own rules. Landlords also cannot end a tenancy to punish someone for reporting unsafe conditions or asking for needed repairs. This retaliation is illegal.
What Happens if the Tenant Refuses to Leave?
Once the notice period ends, the tenant should move out and return the keys. If the tenant refuses to leave, the landlord may need to file a holdover eviction case in court. The landlord must show they followed the law and have the right to recover the property.
Landlords cannot change the locks, shut off utilities, or remove the tenant’s belongings to force them out. Only an authorized officer can carry out a court-ordered eviction.
Can a Tenant End a Month-to-Month Lease?
Tenants can also end these agreements. Outside New York City, tenants generally must give at least one month’s notice. In New York City, landlords should check the rental agreement for notice requirements when a tenant plans to leave.